Hogwarts Legacy is not a Telltale or Quantic Dream game. However, you will still have to make world-changing decisions throughout your game. Yes, many of the choices you make in the game will dramatically change the wizarding world. It is the case to betray Sebastian Sallow or not. After all the events with the Unforgivable Curses and the very dark path that Sebastian Sallow is starting to take, he’s going to go too far with an Avada Kedavra spell. After this mission entitled “In the shadow of the relic”, we will have to discuss with Sebastian then with Ominis to make the big decision: should we report Sebastian Sallow or not?
Related: How to Learn Avada Kedavra at Hogwarts Legacy
What happens when you report Sebastian?
If he decides to denounce Sebastian, Ominis, his friend and fellow Slytherin, will hesitate. Even if he doesn’t think it’s a bad idea in itself, he will let us rectify it with a second dialogue in which we can answer “I changed my mind”, and thus not betray him. If you choose this dialog, see the second answer below.
But be careful. If you insist on betraying Sebastian Sallow again, Ominis will no longer insist on changing your mind. After reporting Sebastian, you will never see him again. Not even in the game’s final mission.
What happens if you don’t report Sebastian?
Let’s say you choose not to report it instead. Whether this is your first choice or you changed your mind after your first attempt to betray him, you will walk down the same path. Your character will say that ultimately Sebastian has learned his lesson and won’t do it again. Besides, you will tell me, Anne is quite alone. She can’t afford to lose her brother too. With this decision, you will continue to see Sebastian, including the final mission.
Source